Who rates skimmers

[mr.wilson]

Originally Posted by Canadian

How about propeller pumps like Ecotech Vortechs or Tunze stream pumps? They address most of the cons of powerheads and consume significantly less power than a closed loop.

These pumps do solve most of the issues I mentioned, and they aren't a bad choice. Personally, I don't want to see any pumps or plumbing, but many people are concerned only about function and not about form.

They do use less power than any closed loop pump currently on the market, but the flow rates they have been designated are not the true values of the water they move. They also deliver volume and very little pressure. A pressure rated pump moves X amount of water plus all the other water it picks up and displaces as it travels across the tank. It's kind of a domino effect. If you were to add a dye to the effluent of the Vortech you would see less of it spread across the tank than what you would see with a typical closed loop pump.

Most of the closed loop effluents I use point up from the bottom to keep detritus suspended and to move dead water from lower regions to the air/water interface at the surface for gas exchange (oxygenation). Vortechs are only suitable for end to end flow, and they do it well.

Closed loop pumps draw in as much water as they put out. So do Vortechs, but the water intake doesn't have any impact on flow dynamics and flow is more turbulent (pumping into walls, rocks & opposing flow) than laminar (circular or rolling effect) without losing velocity due to friction or diffusion.

Typical powerhead set-ups direct water at the reef structure. This is not how it works on natural reefs. Water should change direction to offer suspended food from all angles. Good flow creates a snow globe effect. Chaotic flow with poorly placed powerheads drives detritus into reef structures and the sand bed.

A Sequence Dart pump uses 135 watts, and I pay $0.11 per Kw/h in Toronto including all of the extraneous charges. That comes to less than $11 per month if it runs 24hrs a day. If you can find a more efficient pump that truly moves the same amount of water (3600GPH) at half the wattage then you save $5.50 per month. A savings is a savings, but $5.00 isn't enough to tip the scale much.

I don't have much experience with prop powerheads like the Vortech but they look like they will claim the occasional invert or fish. They also require regular cleaning that you don't need with closed loop systems.

I find that drilling out rocks with a diamond bit or covering PVC ports with concrete or epoxy & aragonite makes them invisible in the tank. I'm trying to get away from swiss cheese tanks with multiple holes to keep costs and liability down. As long as you hide the pipes there's nothing wrong with running them over the top of the tank. You trim $1000 off of the cost of a big tank (no tempering or hole charges), production time is cut in half, and you save on bulkhead and valve costs. This brings the cost down to less than a comparable system with powerheads.