Which Wavebox? (Or Vortech)

[Canadian]

I haven't read the whole thread but considering you're concerned about noise I thought I would mention:

There's a distinct possibility that regardless of whether you choose a Vortech or Wave Box you may run into the problem of noise from your overflow box surging a bit as the wave height crests over the overflow.

I have a Vortech but haven't used a Wave Box so I can't comment the propensity for creating a surging sound in the overflow. I'm not a huge fan of Tunze in general though considering I've had to replace 3 Tunze 6025s in the last year (and the brackets several times) and over the weekend I just found that one of the magnet holders had a leak in the epoxy coating leading to the magnet swelling and rusting for God only knows how long. At this point I'm confident saying I will never buy another Tunze product.

[GreenSpottedPuffer]

Originally Posted by Canadian

I haven't read the whole thread but considering you're concerned about noise I thought I would mention:

There's a distinct possibility that regardless of whether you choose a Vortech or Wave Box you may run into the problem of noise from your overflow box surging a bit as the wave height crests over the overflow.

I have a Vortech but haven't used a Wave Box so I can't comment the propensity for creating a surging sound in the overflow. I'm not a huge fan of Tunze in general though considering I've had to replace 3 Tunze 6025s in the last year (and the brackets several times) and over the weekend I just found that one of the magnet holders had a leak in the epoxy coating leading to the magnet swelling and rusting for God only knows how long. At this point I'm confident saying I will never buy another Tunze product.

Yes I have addressed the overflow problem kind of...It is a herbie, so dead quiet and I want to keep it that way. I know someone who has a very similar tank, overflow and also a wavebox. He gave me some advice that I think will work. Water noise doesn't bother me anyways, its just buzzing noise that does. With the herbie, the drain will not make noise at all even if the level in the overflow changes a bit. The water entering the overflow will make a bit of noise I think but I have already tested that out to see if its loud and as long as its no more than an 1" or so, it still silent.

I have had great experiences with Tunze products over the years. I have had to replace impellers a few times but they did so free. Not really a big deal. For me I don't think I would ever buy another Koralia product! But thats another price bracket...a bit different. If I had your experiences with Tunze stuff, I probably wouldn't buy form them again either.

FWIW, I have heard a fair amount of problems with the Vortechs. Although I think that was the older generation and their customer service seems second to none. I just don't want to pay over $1000 for something that is still not quite going to give me the effect I am looking for. I really want to get that undertow effect all the way behind the rocks on the other side of the tank