What return pump would u buy??

[crimper]

Don't buy a Mag, it's fr3@kin loud. I just wasted a $100 on a noisy pump, it's over rated

[kien]

I've been running the same mag18 on my tank now for over 5 years. Doesn't seem noisy to me. No one ever seems to mention it (any noise). Maybe I'm desensitized. I'll have to ask Brett the next time he's over.

[SeaHorse_Fanatic]

Found Mag pumps to produce a lot of excess heat.

[kien]

Originally Posted by SeaHorse_Fanatic

Found Mag pumps to produce a lot of excess heat.

Which helps me save on my energy bill by reducing run time on my heaters

[gregzz4]

Originally Posted by SeaHorse_Fanatic

Found Mag pumps to produce a lot of excess heat.

Originally Posted by gregzz4

I've used 3 mags over the years and never liked any of them
They lack mounting options/plumbing options, are bulky/heavy, and the ceramic shafts are too delicate (I've broken more than 1)

Originally Posted by kien

Which helps me save on my emergy bill by reducing run time on my heaters

Guess we're all going to have different opinions
At least there's lots of input for the OP here

[kien]

Originally Posted by gregzz4

Guess we're all going to have different opinions
At least there's lots of input for the OP here

Pretty much. With every post comes the disclaimer : your mileage WILL vary. :-)

[Aquattro]

Had a MAG 12 on the 180 for years, loved it. I have an old MAG 3 running my Ca Reactor, I have to feel it to make sure it's running. I do find the newer ones I have are a bit louder.

[gregzz4]

Ya, the little ones aren't bad
I had a mag12 and eventually a mag18 running the chiller on my 125g freshwater
Things were brutes and even sitting on the carpeted floor with all silicone hose they could be heard in the next room ... hmmmmmmmm
And they were pretty warm to touch. Guess it's a good thing they were external

Mags are so much less money than Eheims, so it's hard to decide isn't it ...

[lastlight]

Originally Posted by kien

I've been running the same mag18 on my tank now for over 5 years. Doesn't seem noisy to me. No one ever seems to mention it (any noise). Maybe I'm desensitized. I'll have to ask Brett the next time he's over.

Everytime I'm over you've got your junk exposed so it seems a bit noisy to me. I'm sure with your stand doors closed it's a lot quieter.

Like the others I love the eheim. My mag 12 was pretty quiet, 18 a bit noisier and the 24 makes a serious racket now.

[rishu_pepper]

Gonna go with the Jebao DCT12000 for my new build. Reviews seem to be good for its price/performance.