Let's talk about bio load.

[mikellini]

Originally Posted by Aquattro

Here's my take on that. I don't care at all about any bacteria in water, so if it's there or not, makes no difference. The amount free in the water column is insignificant, so let the skimmer take out however much it wants.

If you're doing zeovit or dosing carbon, there will be a significant amount of bacteria in the water column at times. Enough that you can see clumps

[Aquattro]

Originally Posted by mikellini

If you're doing zeovit or dosing carbon, there will be a significant amount of bacteria in the water column at times. Enough that you can see clumps

Nope, sorry, no clumps. And if there were clumps, that's bound and probably not really active in what I want bacteria to be doing, and therefore, again, insignificant. The only bacteria I'm concerned with are those on substrate, which are not removed in any amount, by any means, that concerns me.

[mikellini]

Originally Posted by Aquattro

Nope, sorry, no clumps. And if there were clumps, that's bound and probably not really active in what I want bacteria to be doing, and therefore, again, insignificant. The only bacteria I'm concerned with are those on substrate, which are not removed in any amount, by any means, that concerns me.

When dosing carbon (and zeo is carbon dosing as well), a biofilm of bacteria is formed. It can form on the sand, rock, zeolites, carbon/gfo, biopellets, glass - whatever. This occurs because dosing organic carbon removes a limiting factor in growth, allowing nitrogen processing bacteria to thrive. These ARE the bacteria you're concerned with. The 'clumps' or biomass bacteria occur when the biofilm becomes too thick, and excess bacteria break off (also happens when shaking zeolites and releasing 'mulm'). But this is just a visual example of what already occurs when dosing carbon; the bacterial count in the water column goes up. You actually WANT to skim/remove these because in doing so you also remove nitrogen and phosphorus from the system. So while it's true that generally you shouldn't be concerned about removing 'too much' bacteria from the water column by protein skimming, that doesn't mean it doesn't happen. It happens to a degree in every reef aquarium, and moreso in those that dose organic carbon.

BTW I do feel this is relevant to the conversation, as dosing carbon (and the resulting increase in bacteria) should actually be considered as an increase in the bioload of an aquarium IMO. That is, if you are dosing carbon, you should increase the capacity of your skimmer accordingly.

[Aquattro]

Like you said, excess bacteria. The ones I don't care about. Maybe I'm just not understanding your point, but I will agree that aggressive skimming is desirable to remove this excess.

[Proteus]

I have only seen clamping in my plumbing. But since dosing biomate it has gone. I do know of carbon dosing peeps who said the rock or sand looked dirty from the mulm build up though. But with proper husbandry it shouldn't get to that point

[mikellini]

Originally Posted by Aquattro

Like you said, excess bacteria. The ones I don't care about. Maybe I'm just not understanding your point, but I will agree that aggressive skimming is desirable to remove this excess.

IMO the solution lies in DC controllable pumps. Get a skimmer that is easily oversized, and turn it down until you get a consistent foam head. Problem solved?

[Aquattro]

Originally Posted by mikellini

IMO the solution lies in DC controllable pumps. Get a skimmer that is easily oversized, and turn it down until you get a consistent foam head. Problem solved?

Really? The last thing I would ever use is a controllable pump on a skimmer. Over complicates things, adds additional cost that doesn't need to be there, and once set, you probably never have to adjust again.
An appropriately matched skimmer/pump set should already be at the right values and the only tweaking should be air volume and water height.

I know I'm old and set in my ways, but adding features for the sake of adding features is not something I buy into.

[reefwars]

Sure Says the guy who's never owned a dc skimmer lol

fwiw dc skimmers are actually cheap for what they are rated to , more so than a lot of the more common AC brand names.


Remember the article on skimmers and how much they actually removed , (less than %20 if i remember correctly ) I believe the reef octopus performed one of the worst yet still a go to skimmer for a lot reefers.So I'm not sure on how good a job our current technology actually is.

Back to the bac.....


While there are bacteria that can and can't be skimmed (see article) the ones that we want are indeed skimmed out ......those rock and surface clinging bacteria everyone speaks of.

But how are they skimmed if they only attach to rock?