Forum Resurrection - Format

[Aquattro]

Originally Posted by Madreefer

Is'nt the point to have the new hobbyists to post questions and have all of us answer them? Not much of a discussion as each of us all have different opinions on how tanks are run.

I think it's best to submit ideas, we'll post the article, then allow a discussion of opinions on it afterwards. Trying to not overwhelm the new reader with too much conflicting info, so probably better to consider basic info first? This is a new (old) idea, so still trying to figure it out.

[Reef Pilot]

Originally Posted by Aquattro

I think it's best to submit ideas, we'll post the article, then allow a discussion of opinions on it afterwards. Trying to not overwhelm the new reader with too much conflicting info, so probably better to consider basic info first? This is a new (old) idea, so still trying to figure it out.

Not sure how you will be able to separate popular opinion from truly good advice. There are many here that are quick to respond based on what they think they know, and not based on direct experience and results from their own tanks.

I know when I was a newbie, I was definitely misled by some, and still see some of the same myths peddled regularly. Fortunately I eventually learned who to trust, and who not to, and of course learned from my own experiences.

If someone is going to post here as an expert, I would like see to a current tank journal thread included as a reference that shows their success (and failures that they learned from). I think that would help newbies to avoid some of the classic mistakes we still see over and over. And which is why many don't last more than a year or so in this hobby.

Maybe even have a sticky thread called Common Newbie Mistakes.

[ScubaSteve]

I'm in as well. Like Myka, I'll do up some serious articles for anything that is requested.

I'm a Chemical and Mechanical engineer who did a PhD in photochemistry and quantum mechanics, has developed several water treatment technologies, currently owns water filter company and am a total SPS nerd.

If anyone has any questions in those areas, being:

Lighting and Corals
Water Chemistry
Water treatment (skimming, dosing, etc)

I can help you out. Feel free to PM me!

[StirCrazy]

Originally Posted by Aquattro

I think it's best to submit ideas, we'll post the article, then allow a discussion of opinions on it afterwards. Trying to not overwhelm the new reader with too much conflicting info, so probably better to consider basic info first? This is a new (old) idea, so still trying to figure it out.

I agree with mad reefer, and if I remember this group was hidden/closed because of opinion battles a long time ago LOL

Steve

[gregzz4]

Originally Posted by Aquattro

I think it's best to submit ideas, we'll post the article, then allow a discussion of opinions on it afterwards. Trying to not overwhelm the new reader with too much conflicting info, so probably better to consider basic info first? This is a new (old) idea, so still trying to figure it out.

Agreed
Having some verified info without a bunch of conflicting or personal ideas would definately help out newbs
I had to pick Mindy's brain for weeks before I knew where to start, and that was after reading on here for a couple months