Data: Wrong; Sustainability: Don't care; Robert Wintner: Aquarium trade should stop!

[gobytron]

I kind of agree with Robert.
Eating is a lot more important than the material satisfaction we get from keeping aquariums.

We play a HUGE role in the destruction of our ocean ecosystems...and forget about the huge wasters of water and power this hobby creates out of all of us.

Personally, while I wouldn't be happy about it, I think it would make a lot of sense to ban aquarium keeping entirely.

[jorjef]

THAT'S IT I'M RETURNING THE MONKEY TO THE PET STORE.....

[Dearth]

Originally Posted by jorjef

THAT'S IT I'M RETURNING THE MONKEY TO THE PET STORE.....

I think your stuck with the monkey heard there was a no return policy on monkeys

[kien]

Originally Posted by jorjef

THAT'S IT I'M RETURNING THE MONKEY TO THE PET STORE.....

If our planet could talk I bet it would be saying the exact same thing.

[jorjef]

Originally Posted by kien

If our planet could talk I bet it would be saying the exact same thing.

Damn you evolution!!!

[kien]

Originally Posted by jorjef

Damn you evolution!!!

Planet Earth: Let them evolve they said. It'll be fun they said. FRAK!
Venus, Mars: LOL !!!

[SanguinesDream]

http://m.youtube.com/#/watch?v=948Nm...%3D948Nm34arfA

RIP dude.

[Dearth]

That is why tank bred fish and coral should be put on the forefront they tend to be much hardier and the likely hood of tank crashes are diminished reducing mass death

[gobytron]

That's probably the second best option, banning of all wild caught fish, coral and collection of Live Rock.

[Myka]

Originally Posted by gobytron

This is why the choice SHOULD be taken out of people's hands...

Originally Posted by gobytron

That's probably the second best option, banning of all wild caught fish, coral and collection of Live Rock.

If that's really how you feel, how do you justify being in the hobby? Is it one of those, "I will do it for as long as I'm allowed, even though I think it is wrong." sort of things for you?

[Maybe we should quit drilling for oil too?]

What about the millions of people who feed their families from their profits in the aquarium trade?

[You better get rid of all man-made plastics and fibers too; carpet, shoes, furniture, clothing, curtains, picture frames, stereos, TVs, canned foods, cars, cell phones, fridges, furnaces...]

In the past fish were caught with cyanide, blasting, and physically breaking apart the reef structures to catch fish. Nowadays, these things still happen but they are frowned upon and people are changing their ways. Indigenous peoples are learning about sustainable collection so there will still be species to collect in the decades to come.

I believe regulation is the answer. Not only does regulation create jobs rather than removing jobs, it also creates a sustainable practice.

Food fishing, cattle farming, oilfields...they are all much bigger problems than the aquarium trade, and all of these challenges affect the oceans and reefs more than collection does.