ICH!!!!!

[mrhasan]

Originally Posted by Madreefer

BAHAHA that did'nt take long. I dont know what the last post says but yes the trick is to have it in the food.

Thanks

[daniella3d]

YOu assume too much and too fast. I do have a nano and love them, just that I love my fish just as much so I make sure they are free of parasites for the rest of their lifes.

I think it is our responsability to make sure the fish in our aquariums are healthy and do to what ever is necessary to keep them that way and give them the best life possible.

I have 2 tank raised clownfish in my nano and quite a few bubble tip anemones and they are happy. Clownfish make excellent fish for nano because in the wild they don't go very far from their anemony, so no big deal if they don't have a large tank.

Originally Posted by mrhasan

And from your post, I think you are not very fond of nanos

There are people, like me, who doesn't have the provision of keeping big tanks (in terms of money and space) and hence nanos are there and they are no big of a difference other than the limited stocking list.

And please don't attack me with the "money" thing because I once had someone attack me with "if you can't get a $50 refractometer, you are in the wrong hobby" because I believe there's more into this hobby than just money and that is dedication. BTW I do have a refrac now :P

[mrhasan]

That's a nice nano you got there

Yes I totally agree that it is our responsibility to take care of them to the fullest. But it is also a part of nature to get sick occasionally just like humans. No matter how clean your house is and no matter how much you take care of yourself, you will occasionally get the nasty stuffs like flu and cold. Its just a part of life and the ecosystem

[daniella3d]

Sure, but when my dog get flea I treat it, I don't leave it full of fleas and let it scratch itself to bloody spots.

Since the dog (or fish) cannot treat themselves it is our duty to do it.

I do not consider parasites to be anything like a cold or a virus. It is easy enough to treat for parasites and be done with it for good.

Originally Posted by mrhasan

That's a nice nano you got there

Yes I totally agree that it is our responsibility to take care of them to the fullest. But it is also a part of nature to get sick occasionally just like humans. No matter how clean your house is and no matter how much you take care of yourself, you will occasionally get the nasty stuffs like flu and cold. Its just a part of life and the ecosystem

[mrhasan]

Originally Posted by daniella3d

Sure, but when my dog get flea I treat it, I don't leave it full of fleas and let it scratch itself to bloody spots.

Since the dog (or fish) cannot treat themselves it is our duty to do it.

I do not consider parasites to be anything like a cold or a virus. It is easy enough to treat for parasites and be done with it for good.

8 weeks of empty tank...kinda hard

And another 4-6weeks of quarantine when adding new fishes....harder

[Pansy-Paws]

Well said daniella3d ...

mrhasan, if it's any consolation, we still enjoy our fish when they are in quarantine ... it's even easier to study them because there is little aquascaping.

One of my favourite savings for marine aquariums, "good stuff happens slow, bad stuff happens fast".

[mrhasan]

Yah I guess I will have to set up a quarantine tank and transfer the fishes over there and leave the tank sit for 8 weeks. In the mean time, I can add corals to the tank right?

[Enigma]

What condition are the fish in right now? How are things progressing? Have you started with garlic? What else do you have in he tank (corals and inverts)?

[Doug]

Beautiful tank Daniella

[Seth81]

I am going through a battle of ICH as well. Mine all started with a blue hippo tang that I did not quarantine when I got him. He was fine for a week or so until he jumped out of the tank while I was trying to rescue him from the overflow. I did rescue him from the floor and he was fine for a day, then ICH took hold of him. My wife and I tried to catch him for at least two hours but couldn't catch him for the life of us. Two days later I noticed ICH on 3 other fish. I have already been soaking mysis and flakes in Kent Garlic and running a UV sterilizer (at proper flow rate).

I have corals and cleaner shrimp so unwilling to do tank wide hypo or copper.

So I went to the LFS and the guy there recommended this Herbatana stuff. It's all natural and reef safe. That was 8 days ago and the ICH hasn't spread past the fish that already had it. But the fish that did have it before are getting worse. I lost the blue Hippo tang yesterday, and I'm sure I'll lose the Flame angel today or tomorrow.

From now on I will QT everything with coppermine. As for what to do now... well I guess just hope UV + Garlic and Herbatana minimizes losses. I would consider moving my coral and shrimp to a seperate tank while I do hypo, but not sure what hypos effect is on my 210 lbs of live rock