Thoughts on clown tang in 180?

[kien]

Clown tangs are actually very difficult to keep. Your best chance of success is to find one that has already been established, perhaps from a previous reefer. They are beautiful fish yet you will notice that there are very few people who have one and there is a very good reason for that. Now, I'm not saying it is impossible, just very difficult. Extra care and attention will be needed if you attempt one, especially if you already have tangs who will likely harass him. This will certainly spell his demise.

The same goes for the powder blue tang actually. Neither of which are typically recommended for "new hobbyists".

[xtreme]

As Kien mentioned they are a tricky fish to keep alive long term. If you do end up getting one to stay healthy in your tank I think you will have a very hard time adding a powder blue and orange shoulder once the clown is established. Acanthurus tangs generally do not get along very well. I don't think your tank is big enough for 3 acanthurus tangs or 7 tangs in total. I have 6 tangs in my 280 and I already foresee them outgrowing the tank down the road. I hate to sound like the TP, but IMO I don't think your tang list will work.

[fishoholic]

Originally Posted by xtreme

as kien mentioned they are a tricky fish to keep alive long term. If you do end up getting one to stay healthy in your tank i think you will have a very hard time adding a powder blue and orange shoulder once the clown is established. Acanthurus tangs generally do not get along very well. I don't think your tank is big enough for 3 acanthurus tangs or 7 tangs in total. I have 6 tangs in my 280 and i already foresee them outgrowing the tank down the road. I hate to sound like the tp, but imo i don't think your tang list will work.

+1

[naesco]

I would add my experience and advise you not to for the same reasons.

I would also really consider changing your wish to add a powder blue to a powder brown. Powder blue are problematic. They do well for a while get sick for no apparent reason, and end up taking a couple of their tankmates with them.

I had a orange shoulder. It got big pretty fast, became a bully as many tangs do but its colour became rather drab as it got older.

Have you reviewed wetwebmedia.com on tanks.? They are pretty right on.

[no_bs]

Heed these warnings, you want to keep things as simple as posible till you get a hang of SW. That way if something goes wrong your not disapointed. You are green at SW, there are so many things you have not encountered yet. You have only had your tank up for a few months now, IMO i would hold off for a while and let your tank stabilize.

[Milad]

well here is what my wish list was for tangs
yellow
mimic
purple
orange shoulder
clown
naso
powder blue

so how should i be changing this?

remove powder blue, clown and orange shoulder from my list and just get a purple and naso?

I really want a good group of tangs with lots of color. suggestions welcome!

[Zoaelite]

In my 170g I have 6 tangs;
1 Purple Tang
1 Yellow Tang
1 2 Spot Bristletooth Tang
1 Chocolate Mimic Tang
1 Lemon Peel Mimic Tang
1 Orange socket Tang (Acan auranticavus)

They all get along very well, I think a big key to that is having an automatic feeder and a VERY large amount of live rock. I added them in the following order:

1. Orange Socket
2. Yellow Tang
2. 2 Spot Bristle
2. Chocolate Mimic
3.Yellow Mimic
4. Purple (The biggest)

I won't be adding any more until I upgrade my tank size. As stated I would stay away from the Clown, powder blue, and possibly the naso. How full is the 180 as far as liverock and coral goes?
Levi