New topic / forum????

G1GY · #1 09-30-2009, 04:55 AM

A QT may be a good idea (I've never used one though.), but I'm not sure that ich is wipiong out your fish. Even if a new and stressed fish has it. Most healthy fish will just fight ich off with no problem at all. Al I ever done for ich was raise my tank temp by a few degrees for a week or so.
Sorry to hear about whats happening with your tank though.

kien · #2 09-30-2009, 05:07 AM

I would agree that pointing the finger at ich is premature at this point. I have never used a QT and I do get ich every few months (usually a sign that I'm behind on my water changes or I've added a new fish. My cleaner shrimp help
with the ich until the fish can fight off the ich themselves. I can't say that I have ever lost a fish to ich and I have 4 ich magnets in my tank, blue tang, purple tang, yellow tang and powder blue tang. All 4 of them enjoy sharing the ich wealth with their tank mates from time to time.

I would investigate other potential causes.

PuffLuv · #3 09-30-2009, 05:11 AM

With such ferocity, and looking like ich, it sounds something more like Brooklynella to me. As far as quarantine use goes in my opinion, its most effective at preventing unwanted organisms from entering the display tank in the first place (meaning holding/treating new additions before putting them in the DT). Anyways, wish you and your fish all the best!

globaldesigns · #4 09-30-2009, 05:20 AM

I also agree, I don't believe it is ICH... If your tank is in proper order, all params are in check and things are happy, then fish can actually live with ICH and also resist it.

I have never had a QT tank and I have many fish that are susceptable to ICH (Blue Tang, Yellow Tang, Sohal Tang, Potters Angel, Flame Angel for example) and at times I see some ICH spots, but overall it never becomes a problem and the fish just continue to thrive.

I would check your tank parameters, there must be another issue that is causing this loss so quickly.

marie · #5 09-30-2009, 06:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by globaldesigns

I also agree, I don't believe it is ICH... If your tank is in proper order, all params are in check and things are happy, then fish can actually live with ICH and also resist it.

I have never had a QT tank and I have many fish that are susceptable to ICH (Blue Tang, Yellow Tang, Sohal Tang, Potters Angel, Flame Angel for example) and at times I see some ICH spots, but overall it never becomes a problem and the fish just continue to thrive.

I would check your tank parameters, there must be another issue that is causing this loss so quickly.

I don't believe ich is that deadly, I think fish that die (from ich) are actually dieing from something else and just happen to have ich at the same time

Marine velvet (the main reason I quarantine everything) can kill a fish in 24hrs...