Everyones an expert

[dabandit]

Originally Posted by Samw

I think the issue is that you accused people of things they didn't do. No one gave advice to overstock the tank and no one gave advice to add phosphates and no one gave advice to use tap water. Yet you are accusing people of that. Here are the posts from the other thread that you are arguing about. The claims that you made about what people said (overstock a tank, add phosphate, use tap water) are not found in these posts and in the thread. And I don't think anyone actually said to add nitrate. They simply made a statement about what is one possible cause of cyano (low nitrate). I think the posts were fairly responsible actually.

Sure those two arent bad,now wheres the ones I was talking about lol? I believe there was over 30 posts in that thread. Two of which said add more fish and at least one said do more water changes,infact the post you have highlighted was a response to the guy who said do more waterchanges. I've been talking via pm's also on that site. So no the issue isnt me accusing people of saying things they didnt. The issue is people like you getting off the issue and turning this into a friggin competion. I have yet to hear someone say that I'm wrong or that theres is the BEST,SAFEST method for a beginner to try period

[Samw]

Originally Posted by dabandit

Sure those two arent bad,now wheres the ones I was talking about lol? I believe there was over 30 posts in that thread. Two of which said add more fish and at least one said do more water changes,infact the post you have highlighted was a response to the guy who said do more waterchanges. I've been talking via pm's also on that site. So no the issue isnt me accusing people of saying things they didnt. The issue is people like you getting off the issue and turning this into a friggin competion. I have yet to hear someone say that I'm wrong or that theres is the BEST,SAFEST method for a beginner to try period

Oh, so I'm the problem now. I thought the issue was about people giving bad advice which if it didn't occur, can't be the issue. Maybe I read the wrong thread. Are we talking about this one?

http://www.bcaquaria.com/forum/showthread.php?t=16159

We can't read what advice was sent to your PM's so all we have to go by is what's in that thread.

[Samw]

.