canister filter

[bv_reefer]

i'm starting to think about getting a decent canister filter, anyone have any good models in mind in partiular that they found have great performance, also canister filters are'nt just for tanks with sumps are they? one model i was really eyeing was the rena filstar XP line of canister filters, the xp1 in particular, anyone have any good or bad experiences with these? also how are canisters for reef tanks?

[Johnny Reefer]

Originally Posted by bv_reefer

....... also how are canisters for reef tanks?

What are you planing to run in it?
I run canisters on my marine tanks. I'm running a Fluval 405 off my Reef tank sump. It has 900 grams of carbon in the 3 lower baskets and 240 grams of Rowaphos in the top basket. No foam.
I'm running a 305 and a 405 off my Trigger tank sump. The 405 is filled with nothing but SeaChem de*nitrate (2 litres). The 305 has 600 grams of carbon in the bottom two baskets and a bit more de*nitrate in the top basket. No foam in these either. (Rowaphos on this tank is run in a reactor).
I have a spare Rena XP3 kickin' about and I'm thinking of running this off my Reef sump with de*nitrate. My sumps are on the floor and so are the canisters. I tried running the XP3 off my Trigger sump, but it didn't have the oompf to draw water for engaging a siphon effect. The reef sump water level is higher, however, so I'm hoping it might work there.

HTH.

[gqlmao]

I have been running an ehiem 2026 for about 2 years, all I can say is great. They are efficient, quiet and the media that came with me is still in there, except the sponge. The only thing that I see as a disadvantage would be the flow on the ehiems, they aren't that great but it does a good job like wise.

[bv_reefer]

Originally Posted by Johnny Reefer

What are you planing to run in it?
I run canisters on my marine tanks. I'm running a Fluval 405 off my Reef tank sump. It has 900 grams of carbon in the 3 lower baskets and 240 grams of Rowaphos in the top basket. No foam.
I'm running a 305 and a 405 off my Trigger tank sump. The 405 is filled with nothing but SeaChem de*nitrate (2 litres). The 305 has 600 grams of carbon in the bottom two baskets and a bit more de*nitrate in the top basket. No foam in these either. (Rowaphos on this tank is run in a reactor).
I have a spare Rena XP3 kickin' about and I'm thinking of running this off my Reef sump with de*nitrate. My sumps are on the floor and so are the canisters. I tried running the XP3 off my Trigger sump, but it didn't have the oompf to draw water for engaging a siphon effect. The reef sump water level is higher, however, so I'm hoping it might work there.

HTH.

-i'm plannin to put 3 types of media, rowaphos as you mentioned, kent reef carbon, and also, nitrite remover

[dsaundry]

I use a Fluval Fx5 for my 72g bowfront..Awesome filter..get it on line... they are usually cheaper..by a lot.

[Pan]

I like the fact that, at least in my experience, the rena xp line is fairly quiet. xp4 was dead quiet xp3 makes gurgling sounds. Now if i really wanted i suppose i could remedy this, but it is almost unnoticiable.

[bv_reefer]

ya a silent filter would be ideal, i was lookin' at the fluvals and gotta admit they're filtration process looks pretty efficient. right now i'm running an aquaclear 30 at the moment with just carbon, but i'm definitely gonna need a filter with more power for when the sps start comin in the tank

[super7]

I work at a fish store and a lot of people come back with the fluval fx5 because it creates a lot of bubbles, this is due to a computer chip or something, if I can remember correctly.
Super7

[bv_reefer]

ya i'm pretty sure i've narrowed it down to a rena filstar, looks pretty efficient, good amount of space for media, and hopefully not too loud

[super7]

the Reanas are a very good filter, and are very quiet. They are used on all the tanks using a canister filter at work, except for the planted tank. They also don't break down, unlike the fluvals.
Super7