Skimmers

Ruth · #1 04-29-2007, 02:40 AM

I have never owned either of those skimmers but I have been on a number of reef boards for a couple of years now and have read various reviews of skimmers.
I think without a doubt the "best" skimmers are Bubble King, H&S and Deltec. They are also without a doubt the most expensive. I own all 3 and can attest to their quality build and ability to pull out massive amounts of gunk - although I have not had the H&S hooked up yet I have no doubt that it will perform well.
I also have an ASM G4X and have to say for the $ it is a great skimmer. Apparently it is not built of the same quality material that a Euroreef is and I do know that I would not trust it not to leak if I decided to run it external.
I think you will find that you pay for quality and long life. Usually the pumps, design, and workmanship will be superiour to some of the cheaper skimmers. As with most things you get what you pay for.
I have of course run the gambit with HOB skimmer, - Remora, Remora Pro, Prism and finally ended up with a Deltec. No question that this is the superiour skimmer in terms of workmanship and performance.
Just my measly 2 bits.

crystalz · #2 04-29-2007, 05:42 AM

Why are you looking at upgrading? Maybe there is a better alternative than upgrading your skimmer. I have the same skimmer only smaller (super skimmer 65) in a 30 gal sump/fuge for a 77 gal main tank. (fish and reef setup) I find this one is more than sufficient. I've left my tank for months without water changes (on occaision) and still had very low nitrates...no ammonia...no film on the top of my water...etc... Although the super skimmer doesn't rate very highly I don't see myself ever upgrading... though I've seen some much nicer units I've been tempted to buy just based on esthetics and ratings.

Kronk · #3 04-29-2007, 03:43 PM

I dont own a CSS i was just wondering why the euro reef rated so much higher... right now i have a prism and it really isnt doing a very good job even with the mods done to it. It skims but i am upgrading to a bigger tank with more fish so i need a better skimmer. Thanks for the reply i have heard mostly good things about peope who own CSS next time one comes up for sale i might go for it, probably just get one that overrated for the tank.

Snappy · #4 04-29-2007, 04:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ruth

I have never owned either of those skimmers but I have been on a number of reef boards for a couple of years now and have read various reviews of skimmers.
I think without a doubt the "best" skimmers are Bubble King, H&S and Deltec. They are also without a doubt the most expensive. I own all 3 and can attest to their quality build and ability to pull out massive amounts of gunk - although I have not had the H&S hooked up yet I have no doubt that it will perform well.
I also have an ASM G4X and have to say for the $ it is a great skimmer. Apparently it is not built of the same quality material that a Euroreef is and I do know that I would not trust it not to leak if I decided to run it external.
I think you will find that you pay for quality and long life. Usually the pumps, design, and workmanship will be superiour to some of the cheaper skimmers. As with most things you get what you pay for.
I have of course run the gambit with HOB skimmer, - Remora, Remora Pro, Prism and finally ended up with a Deltec. No question that this is the superiour skimmer in terms of workmanship and performance.
Just my measly 2 bits.

My next skimmer will be one of these that Ruth refers to, I presently have an Aquamedic and it does a fair job but I know it's nothing like a Bubble King or Deltec.
What size is your tank?

Kronk · #5 04-29-2007, 05:13 PM

With tank and sump it will be around 70gallons. Softies and LPS, 2 clowns, hectors goby, two spot blenny (these guys are so small shouldnt even count as bioload) shrimp, crabs, maybe another small fish or two.

albert_dao · #6 04-29-2007, 06:50 PM

Euroreef's trump CSS skimmers due to better design (better materials, construction, no microbubble problems, better neck union, etc) and a better pump (more reliable air draw vs the RIO's that the CSS skimmers are using).

No one who has owned a Euroreef or better will ever go back to a CSS.

robzilla · #7 04-30-2007, 03:05 AM

i'm going from a css to a pm bullet 2. havent set it up yet but will keep you posted as to my thoughts on this unit

andresont · #8 04-30-2007, 03:18 AM

I woildnt buy anything for less then 500$ (new). From the all skimmers that out there if you want good performance you will have to pay.
The only alternative is to buy a cheeper product, loose money and spend more on better unit.
So in a way if you buy good staff right away you save yourself time money and endup having good product that will sell easy and hold value.
JM2CW

crystalz · #9 04-30-2007, 05:43 AM

k now I understand your reason for upgrade (prism...say no more). If I was upgrading I would consider looking at a downdraft skimmer. You can check out the E.T.S.S. Reef Devil at www.aquacave.com . Seems to me that this style of skimmer is far superior to venturi... Reasonably priced, and they've taken size/design into consideration

albert_dao · #10 04-30-2007, 07:50 AM

Downdraft performance is largely based upon pump selection. Keep that in mind when deciding on one of these units.