small puffers?

[marcingo]

Originally Posted by Flusher

That'll do it, I'm sure. Even a 15 long should be good.



I missed this earlier. Dwarf Puffers are one of the FW-only species.

So when you said this you were refering to FW puffers? I was under the impression you were refering to the valentini puffer- saltwater. What would you consider a good sized tank for a full grown valentini?

Has anyone ever heard of a puffer being raised to leave corals alone? Maybe I can keep him in the 10 gal- and slowly add coral frags from my 55 gal reef (all soft corals in there). Then if he proves to be ok the whole issue of not having a big enough tank for him wont be an issue anymore. Anyone heard of any success stories of puffers who can be raised to be reef safe? My reef is mostly zoos and palys so wouldnt the palytoxin keep him away from the zoos?

[Flusher]

Just to be absolutely clear, all my input should be taken with the understanding that the puffer isn't going to have any roommates. Puffers eat mollusks, crustaceans, and snails. Their beak was designed for that. They are also territorial and aggressive, and don't tolerate other fish, often not even their own kind.

Mr. Scratch, was your experience keeping puffers in a reef tank or in a community setting? If so, yeah, I understand more where you're coming from.

Originally Posted by marcingo

So when you said this you were refering to FW puffers? I was under the impression you were refering to the valentini puffer- saltwater. What would you consider a good sized tank for a full grown valentini?

The basic rules apply for FW and SW puffers. Puffers need lots of water volume because they're messy and not horribly tolerant of poor water conditions. They also need a tank big enough not to stunt their growth.

A 6" puffer needs at least 30 gallons, hands down. A 4" puffer is quite a bit smaller than a 6" puffer (in the same way that a 1" overflow can handle way more flow than a 3/4" pipe). You could put a couple 3"-4" F8 puffers in a 20 gallon tank, but one 6" GSP would be cramped.

The dimensions of the tank are also an issue. A 20 gallon long is better than a 20 gallon tall. There's more surface space and more swimming room.

So, I figure your 20 long would be about as good as a 30 gallon with more standard dimensions. The Valentini's only grow about 4". I think this is a safely do-able fish-to-tank combination, provided you keep tabs on the water quality and keep up on the maintenance to make sure it's good to go.

Has anyone ever heard of a puffer being raised to leave corals alone?

I think mainly it's the clean-up crew they go after, although they do nip corals, probably out of curiosity. I knew another guy who had a Valentini in a reef tank without issue. My understanding is that this is an exception to the norm. Puffers, IMO, should be kept in species-only tanks, and often as singletons. They're worth the extra space.

HTH
________
HEALTH SHOP

[marcingo]

That helps a lot. Thank you for your input.

[Mr. Scratch]

Originally Posted by Flusher

Just to be absolutely clear, all my input should be taken with the understanding that the puffer isn't going to have any roommates. Puffers eat mollusks, crustaceans, and snails. Their beak was designed for that. They are also territorial and aggressive, and don't tolerate other fish, often not even their own kind.

Mr. Scratch, was your experience keeping puffers in a reef tank or in a community setting? If so, yeah, I understand more where you're coming from.

HTH

My experience was with a reef tank, I think puffersare beautiful fish, though valentinis/saddles/mimics are the only ones i tried in a reef. I others in a FO tank but that was a few years ago, and not the type of tank i wanted. The little guys on the other hand, I kept hearing that people succesfully kept them in reef tanks. So after a little research I decided it was worth trying (most of what i read split down the middle as to wether or not they are reef safe) for instance liveaquaria (good place to check basics out if you do not wish to look up more detailed information) lists the valentini as not reef safe, I have had 3 valentinis, I have 1 now that is semi-ok (he kills little shrimp, and nips at things occasionally but I am waiting to decide on him) 2 that i tried were terror in the reef setting, my mimic saddle puffer and my saddle puffer were also horrible, all were returned after a few months to the LFS for a credit, considerably less credit then was used to purchase them i might add.

Here is the write up from liveaquaria.com (please note the information they provide is not always completely correct, but better safe than sorry)

A 30 gallon or larger, fish-only aquarium is suitable. It will fight with conspecifics such as the filefish, large finned fish, and other tobies. It may be aggressive at times, nipping the fins of tank mates, leaving a circular hole as its mark. It will also eat invertebrates found in a reef tank. Its teeth are actually a fused beak-like structure.

[GreenSpottedPuffer]

Hi

I have kept several different Puffers for quite a few years now. There are no Puffers suitable for a 10G except freshwater dwarf puffers. 20G isn't really any better! You need a 30G for a Valentini. I currently have a 65G FOWLR with a Green Spotted Puffer (who spent a year and a half in light brackish, high end brackish and finally marine, a 6 month old GSP should NOT be in marine conditions!), Valentini Puffer, Blue green chromis, Dwarf Lion fish, and Flame Angel. There have been no aggression problems what so ever BUT it all depends on your fish. I have another GSP's that could never have tankmates, it would rip them apart, he is on a 40G, alone. And a 40G is pushing it, as he is just about 6 inches and very thick. My Valentini is about 4.5 inches and also very timid. I would say, the most aggressive fish in the tank is the Flame Angel.

Puffers are very entertaining and fun but you need perfect water conditions and a small tank cannot handle their bio load. Most peoples advice in this thread was right on though and you would do well following it!

Just some thoughts and experiences on Puffers!

Good Luck!