omg... the Ich is back . What's the deal?!?!? I need help.

[Bob I]

[quote="danny zubot"]

I do believe that OCDP is doing the right thing in providing optimum conditions and garlic feeding. Trying to move them when all seems hopeless will kill them for sure.

I don't agree with this at all. Mine were very far gone, almost two weeks after I noticed the first spots. They were very heavily covered and not eating when I finally put them into the Q-tank. After I achieved the salinty of 10 ppt it only took a day or two for the spots to dissapear and thier appitites to come back. Low salinty is what saved my fish. It makes for easier osmotic response.

How can you possibly disagree with something that actually happened to someone

Almost EVERY fish that I have placed in a quarantine/treatment tank has died. Almost all the fish I have placed directly into my aquarium has lived

Therefore my EXPERIENCES dictate not putting a fish into quarantine. Your experiences undoubtedly have validity, but there is equal validity in mine.

There are as many proponents of a given method as opponents. ALL methods if they work are valid.