Artificial reef and corals?

[Coralgurl]

I remember seeing the tank at the rainforest cafe and mandalay bay years ago in Vegas. This was before we had our tanks set up and I can honestly say I could not tell they were fake. Most people have no clue what real corals look like or how they behave, their real colors, movements etc and at that time neither did I. I was truly amazed at what I saw and experienced. I've never snorkeled or been scuba diving. I would admit now having reef tanks and corals I'd be a lot more critical but to the general public it does look natural. I think these fake corals have a place in larger settings like public aquariums. Would I put these in my own tanks?? Not likely but to each their own.

I like mrhasan's tank, it's unique. I've seen some with skulls or sunken ships incorporated into them. It's a vision to the reefer it belongs to.

[nanoreefnewbie]

I'm shocked at all the negative feedback from you guys I get too each there own but there are times too keep mouth shut and give a guy a pat on the back nope some stupid ignorant Daniel or whatever your user name is gotta bash and critize a man's Labour of love...Mr Hasan has started that tank while in school I see on Kijiji other sites student selling tanks cause no time...we should be applauding him not picking apart his tank...WHO care if there is a fake ruin give it a year and it will be soo covered in palys,zoas..
GREAT job mr Hasan that wasn't hard was it..also did you say srry there you ignorant frenchy??that would be a great start not comparing coffee..your lucky Mr Hasan is a good man didn't take that the wrong way...and you got my vote for tank of the month mr Hasan

[jorjef]

Ruins, damn ruins I blame the Greeks for this modern day fiasco. If they would have just knocked those damn pillars down instead of having them stand as eye sores for centuries the French could stop picking on the middle eastern people and the rest of us WASP's could enjoy our nice Central American bean beverages.

[Aquattro]

Originally Posted by jorjef

Ruins, damn ruins I blame the Greeks for this modern day fiasco. If they would have just knocked those damn pillars down instead of having them stand as eye sores for centuries the French could stop picking on the middle eastern people and the rest of us WASP's could enjoy our nice Central American bean beverages.

I was just thinking that very thing!

[reefwars]

Originally Posted by jorjef

Ruins, damn ruins I blame the Greeks for this modern day fiasco. If they would have just knocked those damn pillars down instead of having them stand as eye sores for centuries the French could stop picking on the middle eastern people and the rest of us WASP's could enjoy our nice Central American bean beverages.

[daniella3d]

It's a pain to maintain but maybe since they only have artificial corals they can use products for controlling algae that are not detrimental to fish but are going to kill the algae. I know such product exist but not sure about using those in a reef with live corals.

The main problem is the build up of algae or coraline.

To clean the artificial sponges, I sometimes have to dip them in bleach. I have also notice that they tend to lose their bright color with time and be more dull. Especially the blue.

Also if anyone is going to buy some artificial sponges, it is a good practice to let them dip in water for a few days since I have notice that it can affect the skimmer for a few days. To be safe I dip them for a week now to remove what ever chimical or oil that could be left on it. It never affected the corals or fish but I don't take any chance.

Originally Posted by paddyob

I am at the end of this forum... what was it about anyways?

This got seriously hi-jacked.


Myka.... I am interested in hearing if you found anything out from the staff about how they clean the artificial corals.


I personally think it would be a hassle to maintain... however, after the massive loss of coral I experienced this year.... it is growing on me.


They usually look so fake though.

[intarsiabox]

Originally Posted by paddyob

Myka.... I am interested in hearing if you found anything out from the staff about how they clean the artificial corals.


I personally think it would be a hassle to maintain... however, after the massive loss of coral I experienced this year.... it is growing on me.


They usually look so fake though.

Someone had mentioned they worked a public aquarium with a large display with fake corals. The corals were all on plugs and were removed and replaced immediatly with an alternate while the others were taken out and manually cleaned. Then when the in tank coral needed cleaning again the now clean coral went in and the dirty stuff comes back out to repeat the process.

[untamed]

Only a few weeks ago, I was on a behind-the-scenes tour of the Tampa Bay Aquarium. The guide was explaining how they removed the coral and sponges for cleaning in order to keep things looking nice.

She left it at that. I overheard some of the other attendees talking and had to interrupt..."Ummm...you know that the corals and sponges she referred to are fake....plastic...right?" They hadn't realized that part...

NEVER underestimate how little people understand about nature. My assumption is that 99% of the people who view those tanks think they are looking at real, living coral and sponges.

[Doug]

Originally Posted by mrhasan

I kept it for two reasons:

1. My sister gave it to me on my birthday and that's more important than getting a "yuck" from someone for keeping it.
2. And its gonna look good when it blends in coralines, zoas and monti caps take over it like those artificial reefs in the ocean

Well I think it looks nice.

I remember a thread on RC many years ago, when a lady was taking some flack for all the fake things in here reef, including the bubbly things. She finally said something like, [I dont recall it all], she was a nurse in a childrens cancer ward and when she came home at night she just liked to sit and look at her little tank with the bubbly things to help her cope after a day there, or something to that effect.

I have never forgotten that. So to each their own. Everyone has to make their little or big world what they wish or perceive to be their creation.

[intarsiabox]

Originally Posted by paddyob

I am at the end of this forum... what was it about anyways?

This got seriously hi-jacked.

The OP asked for ideas on the tank he wants to place in the Stollery and artificial coral was brought up. So not too badly hijacked as it is a legitimate idea if someone is willing to clean it.