Newbie advise needed... Diary of a new tank junkie - Page 2

reefwars · #11 01-04-2011, 06:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pirate

Depends on where your return is located. If they are both in the overflow box then make it a drain. Do a herbie, so quiet, My equipement makes most of my noise. In my tank I had a drain in a overflow and the return in the other corner, I herbied it. And have my return coming up over the back. I do see 1 (emergency drain line) but if it had been the return you'd still see it. I like the peice of mind of having a back up, incase something happens.

Same here my skimmers bubbles are the loudest thing I hear, and I get no sump noise or gushing water I have mine made as a true herbie with durso emergency stockman standpipe as my main drain with gate valve and all my returns are housed in through my overflow .

Drilling isn't that hard either if you don't want to run the lines over you could also drill through the back for returns or another drain if your tank is drillable

paddyob · #12 01-04-2011, 06:30 PM

Putting a snail screen on your drain keeps snails out as well. People have been running single drains for a long time and, I agree... if you clean your tank and pipes on occasion you should not have to worry about it.

Sure Denny, a second drain is nice... but not necessary. It comes down to personal choice I believe. Single drain tanks would not be out there if they did not work. Having an emergency drain is something easy to do if, say you build a 200 gallon custom and they factor the cut into it already.

I almost added a second... but after soliciting advice from several reefers and staff at a few LFS, I cam to the conclusion to leave my single drain and clean it and the screen.

Maybe its famous last words.......

reefwars · #13 01-04-2011, 06:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by paddyob

Putting a snail screen on your drain keeps snails out as well. People have been running single drains for a long time and, I agree... if you clean your tank and pipes on occasion you should not have to worry about it.

Sure Denny, a second drain is nice... but not necessary. It comes down to personal choice I believe. Single drain tanks would not be out there if they did not work. Having an emergency drain is something easy to do if, say you build a 200 gallon custom and they factor the cut into it already.

I almost added a second... but after soliciting advice from several reefers and staff at a few LFS, I cam to the conclusion to leave my single drain and clean it and the screen.

Maybe its famous last words.......

A tank need not be custom made for a herbie style overflow and it doesn't need extra real state ......i mean CPR overflow boxes are " safe" but I wouldn't use one even though some say they never had a flood. And call me nuts but constantly moving and cleaning a snail guard( which would have to cover your complete overflow or us no more effective than a stanpipe filter cap) is not fun nor is the worry of it and it's def not pleasing on the eye, again I suggest reading up on herbie style overflows and then say one drain is as good . Fact of the matter is you can do alot of different styles but in the end having a emergency drain makes total sense and if it can be incorporated then it won't hurt in anyway , I also understand that some tanks don't have the option but I don't think that's the case here

herbie all the way baby lol the best fight against floods we have is being prepared for the worst case scenario. I

Melonbob · #14 01-04-2011, 08:32 PM

I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree on this one......

But I guess one could just put in four and fill up your tank with drains. It will look like crud, but will be extra safe. Thousands upon thousands of people have used single drains on smaller tanks for eons with zero issues. In fact I can't think of a single tank I've personally seen under 120 with dual drains.

reefwars · #15 01-04-2011, 08:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Melonbob

I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree on this one......

But I guess one could just put in four and fill up your tank with drains. It will look like crud, but will be extra safe. Thousands upon thousands of people have used single drains on smaller tanks for eons with zero issues. In fact I can't think of a single tank I've personally seen under 120 with dual drains.

I'm sorry wasn't trying to offend you he just simply said he had a concern and if there is something he could do as dril it, I said if he didn't want to drill he had this as another option. Yes lots of people run single drains and all my previous ones were as well but if he wants to do two he should be open to the idea as alot of people are now going that route

cheers

Melonbob · #16 01-04-2011, 08:54 PM

I wasn't offended, thus the

And I agreed from the start, two drains are better than one, but I wouldn't do in in an 80. Maybe I just feel 80 is already cramped after having a 180, and I like as little as possible showing in the tank.

All this talk has got me really wanting to start up again.....man it's tough up here, no used tanks to be found. If the original poster comes across any other deals in YK, I'm interested.

Melonbob · #17 01-04-2011, 08:59 PM

Trust me, I got way thicker skin than these boards put out! After being told on another board for 12 months I was a greedy bully because I was on strike only asking to keep what we already had, this is refreshing! lol

reefwars · #18 01-04-2011, 09:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Melonbob

Trust me, I got way thicker skin than these boards put out! After being told on another board for 12 months I was a greedy bully because I was on strike only asking to keep what we already had, this is refreshing! lol

Have you considered Ordering acrylic and building one?? I know ts expensive as he'll but probably ships better ??

Melonbob · #19 01-04-2011, 09:08 PM

Acrylic scares me, I've only ever had one 30g sump out of acrylic and it let go and dumped on my hardwood floor..........):

I am going to keep my eyes open though, something will pop up.

ensquire · #20 01-08-2011, 05:53 PM

I ordered a proper livestock stand pipe and new fittings etc and am probably going to replumb the overflow box as is. I was seriously considering an outer overflow box but I think I will save that for my next bigger tank. I will find a piece of acrylic and make a cover for the overflow box and keep an eye on it.
What I'm really learning here is that making decisions on the fly isn't all that wise, going slow and planning things before hand is the way to go. but i guess that will be the next tank. LOL