Chemi-Clean

[Chin_Lee]

Mark
if it did get rid of it, then it has worked. I don't believe it claims to free your tank of cyano forever - does it?
If your tank's parameters continue to be a suitable environment for cyano, its inevitable that it will return.

It would seem that you are aware that an RO/DI unit and a better skimmer may improve your tank's parameters however your inability to improve it presently should not be a factor in which we should "get rid" of this product.

Originally Posted by Johnny Reefer

I've been battling cyano since February. I must have done 4 treatments with this stuff since then. The last treatment was just last week. I did 3 doses this time, instead of the recommended 2, and used 20 spoons worth for each dose (180g tank with 33g sump. Probably about 160g net, i figure). Last dose was Saturday. 20% water change, fresh carbon back online and skimmer (for what that POS is worth) back online on Monday. Today!......only 5 days later!!....there I see a new patch about the size of a looney on the sand bed!!!! Sheesh. I realize this stuff is not an end all cure but sheesh!!! 5 lousy days?!!! I am getting sooooo sick and tired of this. Can't wait to move and get an RO/DI system going.....and a better skimmer. Hopefully the move won't make it too much of a new tank, yet again.
Anyway, I'm not impressed with this Chemi Clean crap. It gets rid of it, but not for long, IME.

Cheers,

[Johnny Reefer]

Originally Posted by Johnny Reefer

I've been battling cyano since February. I must have done 4 treatments with this stuff since then. The last treatment was just last week. I did 3 doses this time, instead of the recommended 2, and used 20 spoons worth for each dose (180g tank with 33g sump. Probably about 160g net, i figure). Last dose was Saturday. 20% water change, fresh carbon back online and skimmer (for what that POS is worth) back online on Monday. Today!......only 5 days later!!....there I see a new patch about the size of a looney on the sand bed!!!! Sheesh. I realize this stuff is not an end all cure but sheesh!!! 5 lousy days?!!! I am getting sooooo sick and tired of this. Can't wait to move and get an RO/DI system going.....and a better skimmer. Hopefully the move won't make it too much of a new tank, yet again.
Anyway, I'm not impressed with this Chemi Clean crap. It gets rid of it, but not for long, IME.

Cheers,

Thanx for your input, Chin. Yes, it does work and I shouldn't be so quick to call it crap because it did work in eradicating the cyano in my FOWLR. I haven't seen any cyano in that tank since the first (and only) treatment. I'm just soooo frustrated with my Reeftank cyano and was too focused on that during my little rant above. It's ongoing. What's weird too, is that the parameters on my reeftank are consistently better than my FOWLR so I woulda thought that it'd be the FOWLR that would be a problem, not the reeftank.
Anyhoo, upgrades to RO/DI, better skimming, and a refugium are pending soon (I hope).

Cheers,