LiveRock in Canada?

[Goatman]

Originally Posted by whatcaneyedo

Colour is irrelevant. Algae growth in your tank will change the colour of the rock within a few months or less. After a couple of years of coral growth (if you plan on keeping a reef tank) you won't be able to see very much of your rock anymore period. Liverock is a biological filter and base in which to mount coral. Shape, porousness/porosity(?) should be your main concerns (for a reef tank).

Main, not only. Aesthetic appeal matters to some. Having lived where there is liverock we cannot get, yes it makes a difference aesthetically...at least in the beginning. But you are right after awhile it will look similar to each other however in no way is it all identical.

After All look at tampabay saltwaters liverock that they have seeded...mind you it is in the ocean so perhaps a bit unfair for a comparison.
However a tank that has say dry rock put in with a little liverock looks a certain way.

Perhaps he does not want that. One can have, or attempt to have an aesthetically pleasing tank from the start....cycling issues aside.

Perhaps he was also meaning the shapes available to him at jl were not what he wished. And yes liverock CAN be and IS different colors for the life of your tank depending on what kind you use, its simple fact. Close up you can tell the subtle differences in liverock...for it is not all the same.

[AquaPin]

I would suggest talking to J&L and finding out when their next order comes in and be there to pick through it at that time. I have gone in the day of / day after and have always been happy with what I can find. Really nice shapes, variety of coraline algae colours, even had GSP, mushrooms, button polyps, and other neat stuff growing off of it. Just be sure that this is for a new tank as the smell and die off is very strong.

[whatcaneyedo]

Originally Posted by Goatman

And yes liverock CAN be and IS different colors for the life of your tank depending on what kind you use, its simple fact. Close up you can tell the subtle differences in liverock...for it is not all the same.

Maybe from the underside but the colour of liverock exposed to light is the colour of the algae growing on it. This picture contains one or two pieces of base rock and two or three pieces of liverock all from different sources.



I think there is liverock in my display from 5 different sources and one or two pieces of base rock as well... at this point it really doesn't matter anymore. But I agree, it would have been nice to have been able to buy everything from a single source initially and sometimes the selection at stores gets cherry picked heavily. I just wouldn't concern myself with colour when selecting live rock.

[WarDog]

Thanks for all the useful information, I will keep it in mind.
Yes this rock would be for a new reef (my first), and yes I understand that the main point of having live rock is for filtration and that over the years it would be completely covered in corals. Frankly I was hoping that if you had liverock with lots of pastel colours or bright pinks and reds that those coralines would remain dominent in the tank down the road... even after cycling and die-off. If I am going to be spending hundreds of $$$ just on liverock, is it too much to ask for something unique rather than just some more purple rock?... not that these tanks look bad at all. I just ordered a new car from the factory... red... there are plenty of blacks, greys, and whites on the lot... and the road... but I don't want to be like everyone else.

[Aquattro]

Unfortunately those colors will likely not stick around more than a month or 3. I've had lots of rock with reds and pinks, but it all quickly goes purple. I'm guessing due to the lighting used on reef tanks. If you can find it, fine, enjoy it for a month or so, but don't kill yourself trying to find something that you won't end up keeping.

[WarDog]

I am starting to think this will be the case... J&L's not looking too bad now i guess. LOL. Thanks!

[PurpleMonkey]

I have some pretty persistent red coralline algae... You can always grab a bit from me

[WarDog]

I am still in the 'purchase and research' phase of my build. Probably 6-9 months away from getting wet, but thanks for the offer!

[WarDog]

Just for the record... this is what I'm after!