Carbon - Yes or No?

[reefwars]

Originally Posted by Delphinus

Well now wait. I can't answer this without knowing the unstated assumptions. What other variables are there? Is said desert island near good reefs? Is the snorkeling any good? Wait, what, is there food to eat? Because I hear tangs are delicious and if I'm stranded anyhow I might need to eat something sooner or later. But fish are friends not food. I'm so conflicted! Argh!

lol , im just looking out my window at the snow and i think i got side tracked about what i was even talking about and got to talking about where id actually like to be :P