110g Mixed Reef V2

[fishytime]

Originally Posted by ensquire

Awesome pics.

thanks Mike


Ive been doing alot of thinking lately about what the stock list for V3 of my reef might look like as far as fish goes.....V2 has way too many fish for it own good.....most are in the "must keep" category, a few are in the "must be re-homed" category and a couple ( with one fish in particular) Im really struggling with what to do with..... heres how my current list shakes down....

5 green chromis:.....must keeps....these guys started as a group of 14 and whittled their way down to 5 rather quickly....the five survivors have been five for a few monthes now.....they still on occasion swim as a group(in between brief spats), which I think is cool..... I may try and enlarge the group in V3 and see what happens

4" "Winky" the one eyed banded shrimp goby: ....must keep.....Winky spent over a year at the old shop because nobody wanted to buy a one eyed goby....I took pity on him and brought him home....he's been with me ever since.....he has a little trouble tracking and catching food, but despite this, has turned form a shy reclusive fish to a bold, cantankerous old bugger....

3 1/2" royal gramma.....must keep......just cuz he's pretty....and mellow....

2" yellow assessor......must keep.....same as above

3" flame hawkfish.....must keep.....cuz he's too cool for school

3" leopard wrasse..... must keep.....one of those harder to keep fish thats doing incredibly well

3 1/2" melenarus wrasse.....must keep .....too pretty and too beneficial not to keep

4" powder blue tang.......MUST keep......another harder to keep fish....that is finally doing well for me.......not a blemish on him and super playful.....my hands down favorite fish in the tank.....

3" Lubbocks wrasse......must keep.....just cuz





2 1/2" sunrise dottyback..... must re-home.....he's got quite the attitude.....most of my fish can handle him......one cant.....my yellow assessor.....the only fish in the tank thats smaller than the dotty.....I like my assessor too much so the dotty has to go....

3" coral beauty.....must re-home.....bought this guy as a "deep water" coral beauty....colors changed to a regular beauty....I would much rather have a potters, so ..... he's on the nix list

2 1/2" african flameback angel ..... must re-home.....stunning looking fish but he picks at EVERYTHING.....so he 's gotta go....


now on to the tough decisions........

4" yellow tang......my plan was to re-home this guy and introduce a trio of small yellows.... the shop got in some small Hawaiians and I took three up to E-town at X-mas and put them in Laurie's 80g....the thought was to wait til the tank had settled down a bit and add the trio that had been co-habitating for a couple monthes all at once......one yellow didnt do the three hour drive well and ended up dying the next day....we went to RCE that day and Steve had a few of the same Hawaiian yellows in so I thought I would grab another one, before the other two had a chance to settle in....so there were three again......another one ended up dying a couple days later and I decide not to spend any more money on tangs, so that left two......which didnt work out so well....the dominant one picked on the sub for a couple weeks and the weaker one then died from stress........so now I have a small yellow in E-towm and a big yellow here in Ctown......not sure what Im gonna do about the situation now



now heres the one Im REALLY struggling with.....Chevy......my 5 1/2" chevron tang......I love him to death but the reality is, even a 260g tank will be to small for a fish that has the potential to reach 15" .....my head says, re-home him while you have the chance.....my heart doesnt wanna let him go.....he probably wont reach a size to where he will be an issue for a couple years, but then Im faced with the more difficult task of trying to re-home a 8-10"(just guessing here) fish instead of a 5" fish..... I told Laurie this morning that I was considering re-homing him and she dang near killed me....Im torn......



looking for insight and opinions......what would you do?

[Delphinus]

I don't know if this helps or not .. but ... in ~15 years in the hobby I have yet to see a Chevron tang anywhere near that big. I thought they maxed out at more like 10"-11" anyhow but that's in the wild. I see him getting a little bigger on you but not by much.

[BlueTang<3]

I say buy more fish, I am sure if you don't Laurie wont have any problems filling the tank for you.

[christyf5]

Originally Posted by Delphinus

I don't know if this helps or not .. but ... in ~15 years in the hobby I have yet to see a Chevron tang anywhere near that big. I thought they maxed out at more like 10"-11" anyhow but that's in the wild. I see him getting a little bigger on you but not by much.

I haven't even seen one at 10". Biggest one I have seen was about 8" or so and full grown, the guy had had him for 6+ years. If I were you I'd risk it and keep him.

[kien]

In my experience when you get rid of fish that you absolutely ador you just end up trying to replace him/her down the road anyway...

[fishoholic]

Originally Posted by BlueTang<3

I say buy more fish, I am sure if you don't Laurie wont have any problems filling the tank for you.

so true

FYI I will kick your a$$ if you sell chevy!!!!!!!!! Like Kien said we'll just end up replacing him so we might as well keep him.

[The Grizz]

Originally Posted by fishoholic

FYI I will kick your a$$ if you sell chevy!!!!!!!!!

Looks like you are keeping Chevy, Doug!

"2 1/2" african flameback angel ..... must re-home.....stunning looking fish but he pick at EVERYTHING.....so he 's gotta go...."

I have a FOWLR it would go well in

[fishytime]

Originally Posted by Delphinus

I don't know if this helps or not .. but ... in ~15 years in the hobby I have yet to see a Chevron tang anywhere near that big. I thought they maxed out at more like 10"-11" anyhow but that's in the wild. I see him getting a little bigger on you but not by much.

Originally Posted by christyf5

I haven't even seen one at 10". Biggest one I have seen was about 8" or so and full grown, the guy had had him for 6+ years. If I were you I'd risk it and keep him.

I think it was the surgeonfish/rabbitfish book that listed them at a 15", but, you both are probably right.....highly unlikely that our captive fish will ever reach full potential....regardless, my Chevy is the biggest chevron Ive personally seen......I guess ultimately , I just feel that a 10" fish deserves a bigger home than a 260g.....although the reality is, how many people out there have a tank much bigger than that?....I mean I know there are quite a few here and there but the percentage of tanks larger than Im doing are small

Originally Posted by kien

In my experience when you get rid of fish that you absolutely ador you just end up trying to replace him/her down the road anyway...

your right too man.....I know I would miss him....... even tho he's a big lipped, lumbering, clumsy(I have seen him with more than a few scratches on his head), bully of a fish....I would want another one.........I have no idea what Im gonna be doing as far as work goes, so a $200 tang may not be possible financially for me up there....

[fishoholic]

Originally Posted by The Grizz

Looks like you are keeping Chevy, Doug!

"2 1/2" african flameback angel ..... must re-home.....stunning looking fish but he pick at EVERYTHING.....so he 's gotta go...."

I have a FOWLR it would go well in

Heck ya he is! (keeping chevy)

FYI the plan for the flameback was for it to go into my 80g

[Skimmerking]

Doug when you re talkng about chevy I look at butt head my Kole he is 10 years old and he is the size of a whopping 5 " if that and they are said to grow big but mine have now reached that size. Just sayin I would keep him . but im going through that say thing I have to downgrade and would rather a a crap load of smaller fish my busy like in the tank.. P>S

That Scolly is one sexy piece of coral I think i must have it.

Just Sayin

Originally Posted by fishytime

thanks Mike


Ive been doing alot of thinking lately about what the stock list for V3 of my reef might look like as far as fish goes.....V2 has way too many fish for it own good.....most are in the "must keep" category, a few are in the "must be re-homed" category and a couple ( with one fish in particular) Im really struggling with what to do with..... heres how my current list shakes down....

5 green chromis:.....must keeps....these guys started as a group of 14 and whittled their way down to 5 rather quickly....the five survivors have been five for a few monthes now.....they still on occasion swim as a group(in between brief spats), which I think is cool..... I may try and enlarge the group in V3 and see what happens

4" "Winky" the one eyed banded shrimp goby: ....must keep.....Winky spent over a year at the old shop because nobody wanted to buy a one eyed goby....I took pity on him and brought him home....he's been with me ever since.....he has a little trouble tracking and catching food, but despite this, has turned form a shy reclusive fish to a bold, cantankerous old bugger....

3 1/2" royal gramma.....must keep......just cuz he's pretty....and mellow....

2" yellow assessor......must keep.....same as above

3" flame hawkfish.....must keep.....cuz he's too cool for school

3" leopard wrasse..... must keep.....one of those harder to keep fish thats doing incredibly well

3 1/2" melenarus wrasse.....must keep .....too pretty and too beneficial not to keep

4" powder blue tang.......MUST keep......another harder to keep fish....that is finally doing well for me.......not a blemish on him and super playful.....my hands down favorite fish in the tank.....

3" Lubbocks wrasse......must keep.....just cuz





2 1/2" sunrise dottyback..... must re-home.....he's got quite the attitude.....most of my fish can handle him......one cant.....my yellow assessor.....the only fish in the tank thats smaller than the dotty.....I like my assessor too much so the dotty has to go....

3" coral beauty.....must re-home.....bought this guy as a "deep water" coral beauty....colors changed to a regular beauty....I would much rather have a potters, so ..... he's on the nix list

2 1/2" african flameback angel ..... must re-home.....stunning looking fish but he picks at EVERYTHING.....so he 's gotta go....


now on to the tough decisions........

4" yellow tang......my plan was to re-home this guy and introduce a trio of small yellows.... the shop got in some small Hawaiians and I took three up to E-town at X-mas and put them in Laurie's 80g....the thought was to wait til the tank had settled down a bit and add the trio that had been co-habitating for a couple monthes all at once......one yellow didnt do the three hour drive well and ended up dying the next day....we went to RCE that day and Steve had a few of the same Hawaiian yellows in so I thought I would grab another one, before the other two had a chance to settle in....so there were three again......another one ended up dying a couple days later and I decide not to spend any more money on tangs, so that left two......which didnt work out so well....the dominant one picked on the sub for a couple weeks and the weaker one then died from stress........so now I have a small yellow in E-towm and a big yellow here in Ctown......not sure what Im gonna do about the situation now



now heres the one Im REALLY struggling with.....Chevy......my 5 1/2" chevron tang......I love him to death but the reality is, even a 260g tank will be to small for a fish that has the potential to reach 15" .....my head says, re-home him while you have the chance.....my heart doesnt wanna let him go.....he probably wont reach a size to where he will be an issue for a couple years, but then Im faced with the more difficult task of trying to re-home a 8-10"(just guessing here) fish instead of a 5" fish..... I told Laurie this morning that I was considering re-homing him and she dang near killed me....Im torn......



looking for insight and opinions......what would you do?