Sea Apples - experiences/thoughts?

[Whatigot]

no clue why your cuke bit it triggerman?

I know I'll have to make sure powerheads are apple proof.....

[Trigger Man]

Not a clue, Ph were up high in a area that the cucumber did not go near, all the rockwork was the same ( so nothing fell on him), I'm guessing one of my fish finally decided to see if it was tasty. The Cucumber was 4 inches long.

[Treebeard]

We have had one in our tank for around 8 months now with no issues. Nobody picks on it and we do not feed it anything special. It is very cool to watch it eat, but unfortunately, since we moved to our new tank, it has settled into an area near the back of the tank and we do not see him much. Next time I am messing in the tank I will try relocating him.

[Whatigot]

treebeard, this is a sea apple you're talking about?
man, i would LOVE to see apic of him in your reef...

thanks so much for the positive spin.

[Treebeard]

If I get a chance I will move him tonight and take some pics after he settles in. He tends to go where he wants though so no guarantees!

[Whatigot]

no pic necessary, would be cool though...
What would really help would be a good description of your tanks equipment and inhabitants?

[GreenSpottedPuffer]

Originally Posted by Whatigot

agreed, everyone agrees, not worth the risk...
however, I might risk it.

Then what exactly are you asking?

[Whatigot]

Originally Posted by Whatigot

nobody else carries them, and you're talking to a guy who lives to wheel n deal...lol
and really ,where can you buy anything marine that isn't overpriced?

I know that they can wipe the tank out, I guess nobody has ever had one or has any links to experiences with them?
I know most consider it not worth the risk, I understand the risk and will debate that for myself once I have some knowledge on them to work with...

I may have to be the first one on this board to try one out.
I can't imagine that I would have any stress in my tank for it and I would certainly spot feed it to make sure it's healthy and happy...

You ever seen something and it just appealed to you?
I'm enamored of this sea apple...lol

think I'm being pretty clear here but just to eloborate for ya greenspot...
I'm not looking for people (who mostly seem to have never had one) to simply say, not worth the risk, can wipe out the tank, etc, etc, my appetite for risk is my own as is the tank I want to risk
I was looking for comments like treebeards, who actually has experience with this animal.
any links to info where there is direct experience keeping them in a reef or aquarium setting (like your rc thread that you vaguely mentioned) would be greatly appreciated as well.

I do appreciate everyones concern, but I think it's clear it's risky at this point.

[Pier Pressure]

I had one for quite some time in my little reef and he seemed to do okay. I ended up taking him back to the LFS as he was not getting enough food in my tank. One of the saltwater stores here in Calgary has them in just about ALL of their tanks, and the dude who runs it says he has seen one ripped in half and that did not even cause a problem. If you are looking for positive feedback, you may wish to give Colby at Elite a call.

[Whatigot]

positive/negative, as long as it's relevant...
thanks very much for your experience.
Whats elite?
sorry, I have no clue but would certainly like to follow up on your comment...