Refractometer or hydrometer

[Kellyscoral]

2 days ago my hydrometer cracked. I bought another and readings seemed impossibly high - so I bought another - and then another. Each one had a different reading. So now I'm thinking a should get a Refractometer. Curious to see what you all use - and what brand/where should I purchase one from.

Thanks

[SoloSK71]

refractometer, no other choice for me

Charles

[Aquattro]

Not only will your hydrometer be wrong, it will change over time. Refractometer is the only way to go.

[JmeJReefer]

Refractometers are exponentially more accurate. Even an air bubble will throw off salinity readings in a hydrometer!

[Slyguy00]

People still use those hydrometer things???? This shouldn't even be a question

[gregzz4]

Be sure to buy some calibration fluid when you get your new Refractometer
Then you'll never look back

[mrhasan]

Originally Posted by Kellyscoral

2 days ago my hydrometer cracked. I bought another and readings seemed impossibly high - so I bought another - and then another. Each one had a different reading. So now I'm thinking a should get a Refractometer. Curious to see what you all use - and what brand/where should I purchase one from.

Thanks

Like others said. Refracs are the only way to go (unless you can drop $120+ for a digital one). Any brand is fine as long as it has ATC. Vertex is possiblY the most popular.

[hillegom]

Or buy a used one. Use the search button on tool bar above thread.
Here is one in the lower mainland just to show you they are available reasonably. you will have to search for one in calgary

http://www.canreef.com/vbulletin/sho...=refractometer

[mike31154]

While I'm not a fan of the swingarm hydrometer, if not calibrated periodically, a refractometer can also easily give you false readings. They are delicate & I find mine creeps off calibration fairly easily. I've used my refractometer to calibrate the swingarm hydrometers I have, so they're just as accurate provided I go by the marks I put on them after comparing with refracto.

Not sure why the floating glass type hydrometer is not used or offered for sale in our hobby very much either. They can be quite accurate, the only thing you need to be aware of with these is temperature compensation. I wish I still had mine, but broke it some time ago. I still have a larger floating glass hydrometer for beer & wine making. I've used that to measure tank water as well, out of curiosity, and it was bang on with refracto reading.

Posted these photos before, but here they are again. Comparison of 2 swingarm hydrometers & floating glass. If I recall correctly, the refractometer reading was 1.025. The floating glass was pretty much bang on.

Coralife, 3 points low


IO Deep Six, better but 1.5 points low


Floating Glass, on the money


So yeah, based on my personal experience, by all means get a refractometer, it's a good investment. Floating glass will also serve you well at a fraction of the cost. Both are delicate, the refracto needs calibration, the floating glass does not, but needs temperature compensation. Most floating glass are factory calibrated to provide an accurate reading at a given temperature, which is not that far off the temperature we run our tank water at. They will usually come with compensation chart and a few degrees difference does not affect the reading that much.

[Kellyscoral]

Thanks all - last weekend I bought a new radion light and this weekend I will go buy a Refractometer! Gives me a good excuse to go check out coral too!