PO4 test kits

[Edmonton Eskimo]

Is there an accurate test kit for phosphate? I have a seachem and it's brutal!

[trilinearmipmap]

I have the expensive phosphate test kit from J & L, I think it is called Merck D & D, it cost about 70 bucks.

I found other PO4 test kits were unreliable.

I rarely need to test phosphate, I find you need to test it once to see if you have a phosphate issue or not. Kind of expensive to buy a $70.00 test kit that you will use once only.

If anyone needs their phosphate tested they can send me a sample as long as they are willing to add to my collection of macroalgae by sending me some macroalgae along with their water sample.

[calkrog]

i found testing for phosphates is pretty much irrelevant, as much of the phosphates are bound in your rocks and not in the water. if you have algae you have too much and you need to run a reactor, if you dont have algae you dont need to worry. IMO.

[Matt]

I have never had a positive result for phosphates with the tests I've done, but I know if I start adsorbing it, my algae starts to brown and recede, so it must be there. Apparently most of the test kits only test for orthophosphates (saying that just like I know what it means), so they aren't very good at determining actual levels.

The Hanna Colorimeter is said to be an excellent way to test, but it is an expensive thing for a low-level hobbiest like me to afford. If we had a proper "reef club" locally, maybe it would be the kind of thing to have as a lendable resource.

I've stopped testing for phosphates. I'm concentrating on getting rid of it instead.

Cheers,
Matt
<edit>
Re-reading Randy Holmes-Farley's "Phosphate and the Reef Aquarium", recommended to everyone interested in the phosphate discussions that have recently sprung up all over the board. Stick with it to the end!