Yeah getting a stucco guy out here to do such a small job isn't worth it, it'll cost twice as much as the rest of the material so I'll paint it flat before I do that.
I've been looking for paneling but can't find it anywhere, seen pictures online but no stores carry anything like it.
I found this:
http://www.lowes.com/pd_352095-82763...ductId=3539044
Basically super thick paint that allows for a decent texture and hardens to a stone type feel. Should cost around a $1/sqft so not bad.