The important thing here is time lines. I made my original assessment back in October of 2010 and I stand by it. At the time, the Vertex light used Phillips Luxeon Rebels and Pacific Sun was using Cree XPE and XPG. The Pacific Sun lights also had T5 supplemental lighting.
Here is a comparison chart for the Vertex lights:
Source:
http://www.masns.ca/forum/showthread...4865&pid=45054
I've done a lot of research into LED fixtures. I've discussed the technology with more than one manufacturer directly. There is no golden rule for what works, but in my opinion, the combination of 3W Cree XPE and XPG LEDs is the minimum requirements for keeping SPS. The original Vertex Illumina 200-P just wasn't what I was looking for.
I don't think I've ever said anything negative about Pacific Sun. In fact, I still think they are a fantastic lighting solution.
The Vertex 260 Illumina was the game changer and became the standard to which other manufacturers are measured. Pacific Sun holds it's own and for many people it is the right solution.
Honestly, I am happy to recommend either solution.
- Brad
(Why did we bump such an old thread?)
Quote:
Originally Posted by phi delt reefer
would you have taken the Pacific Sun fixtures over the Illumina?
|
At this point no. I love my Vertex light and I wouldn't trade it for anything.