[OCDP]

Ok.. well, once again, I always end up feeling like the bad guy. Sorry I am not communicating clearly.

I said "I love Sailfin's" Not, "I love sailfins, I think I'll add one of those ..." So, IMO , I was hounded on for no reason.

After 2 years in the hobby I think you all should know that I have a darn good idea of general care requirements for tangs.

This thread was specifically meant to find out (in your experience) What the hardiest tang is. I said "I am thinking of adding one if I can get a big enough setup" .. key word: Thinking.... meaning I am thinking a tang would be nice in my new setup. Doesn't mean I am adding one, and I never said "I am adding a tang to my new setup" .

And yes, I should have specified that I am now looking at a longer tank rather than a cube, as width may be an issue. Sorry for not specifying.

Sorry if I came off defensive in the original post, i didn't mean to come off that way. Just, tangs are too touchy of a subject for some people and it drives me bonkers that they jump right on you when I haven't even said I AM adding a tang. I said I am THINKING of adding a tang, IF I can get a big enough setup.

Once again, my apologies .. this thread took a turn for the worse, all's I wanted to really know here was in your experience what is the hardiest tang.

I will re-edit my original post.