I got what you meant Mindy!  I think when I get home I will hit the LFS and get them to test the water as well for a second opinion.  Seems like PO4 is really high on the test but it didn't reflect looking at the tank. 
1 more day and I will be able to get it sorted out. 
FTR - some nice diving around Maui (Lanai, Molakai, Molkini).  Lots of different fish out and about and was fortunate enough to see lots of the whales 
