Canreef Aquatics Bulletin Board - kien's Ecoxotic Panorama 36 LED Retrofit review

Canreef Aquatics Bulletin Board (http://www.canreef.com/vbulletin/index.php)

- Lighting Specific (http://www.canreef.com/vbulletin/forumdisplay.php?f=173)

- - kien's Ecoxotic Panorama 36 LED Retrofit review (http://www.canreef.com/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=71857)

Quote:

Originally Posted by kien (Post 582593)

I don't plan on putting it anywhere on my system at the moment and I don't have a refugium :) I could see it going over maybe a softy tank or FOWLR in the future. :)

Maybe a fishroom light?

Have you tried any PAR measurements without the diffuser?

Quote:

Originally Posted by shrimpchips (Post 582638)

Maybe a fishroom light?

Have you tried any PAR measurements without the diffuser?

I may try testing it without the diffuser tonight but I would not want to run it long term over saltwater without a cover. Salt creep would likely destroy the LEDs and small reflectors.

Nice review, this will certainly save some unsuspecting new buyer the same purchase.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seamazter (Post 582648)

Nice review, this will certainly save some unsuspecting new buyer the same purchase.

Or help some buyers make this purchase :). The light does have its applications. Plus, remember that this was just one unit.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seamazter (Post 582648)

Nice review, this will certainly save some unsuspecting new buyer the same purchase.

I agree. If you can't run a product out of the box like a light the way manufacturer intended I'd perhaps look at other options. Perhaps a unit with a glass shield. Do most have that?

Quote:

Originally Posted by the marine apprentice (Post 582607)

kein whats the price on one of these fixtrures? pm me with details please

Let me know if kein doesn't get you that info, as I can get it to you if he doesn't.

Quote:

Originally Posted by mseepman (Post 582587)

Thanks for the review. Decent looking retrofit light.

I'm planning on a a DIY LED build over my next tank and have been purchasing parts for it already. LED's have a lot factors tied to them and their success over a tank, specifically the quality of the LED's used and the optics used. In looking at the Ecoxotic site, I didn't see any indication of the brand of light being used. The difference in lumin output from brand to brand is staggering. They also appear to be roughly 1W LED's and most LED's now being used are 3W.
Interestingly, regarding the PAR output, there have been a lot of comments made on forums, especially RC and NR that suggest PAR meters haven't been giving them results that made sense. People with tanks and multiple 400W lights have found that LED fixtures have overwhelmed their corals, even though the PAR meter gave fixtures similar numbers.

The advantage of the 1 watt LEDs from what I've read is that they are more energy efficient and since they are lower power and it is spread out more on the heat sink they are less apt to require a fan. Most of the newer 3 watt fixtures have fans. No fan equals good to my ears.

I have also read about the par meter issue with LEDs. I suppose a fair model for comparisons remains to be worked out. A less bright looking tank may actually suit me fine, sometimes looking into my yank feels like I am staring into the sun. According to the website this fixture is equivalent to comparable 150 watt plus light sources, whatever that means.

Quote:

Originally Posted by soapy (Post 582654)

In the instance of the 1W versus the 3W, efficiency is probably not the right word as the new 3W lights are the most efficient...simply run them at lesser current and they still put out way more lumens but don't require a fan. A 3W Cree XP-G can use up to 1500mA but at about 1000mA you are probably getting the biggest bang for your buck and you are only running it at 2/3's the power and heat. Use the right heatsink and no fan is required....cheap out on the heatsink and you need a fan.

Right, hopefully somebody will set up a fixture like that. I am not that keen on listening to a fan grinding away.

Quote:

Originally Posted by mseepman (Post 582587)

Thanks for the review. Decent looking retrofit light.
They also appear to be roughly 1W LED's and most LED's now being used are 3W.

Good thread Kien:biggrin:
Mark,
I also looked at their website and I can't find anywhere they state the actual bulb wattage and since the tanks they show as examples don't appear to contain any high light demanding corals I think it's probably safe to assume they use the lower wattage bulbs.