fishoholic is absolutely right with any of these its hit or miss some do great jobs others do nothing depends on your system and what it offers to the breed of fish.for me lemon juice and a syringe has worked in the past with my newer tanks if its a small piece i just remove the rock and kill the anemone.some say boiling water or joes juice works well.i know people who have butterflies who eat it and barely pick at anything else but they have a bad rap:):)

i have it every ware i need something to eat it lol

it is a real pain unfortunately there is no quick answer like anything in this hobby lol pick your battles take out small amounts and start fighting back it will spread even faster the more it grows.have you ruled out getting a copperband butterfly they will eat it right up but along with any other tasty corals in there plus there not the smallest fish at a mature age too big for anything small. how much live rock do you have??

You should be ok with a filefish, your tankmates probably won't bother one and from what I understand they mostly eat sps corals. Ken at Blue world could get one in for you.

yea i only have softies,i dont have alot of live rock only about 40lbs but thats my entire tank :P

i say give it a shot mines in with like a dozen other fast moving large fish and he does fine hes also a really cool fish to watch hes beautiful in an ugly kinda way lol:)

make sure you get a matted filefish:)

I have a file as well and love mine - did a great job cleaning up the odd one I had in the rocks...