so in fact not only did you kill the valonia but all the bacteria, pods and pretty much everything that makes "live" rock live then. what exactly was the point of adding live rock in the first place if you going to kill it making soup out of it?

try getting an emerald crab


http://www.jlaquatics.com/phpstore/s..._ID=rc-emerald

Well, duh, yeah, if you boil the rock everything freaking dies :rolleyes: But what's the point of maintaining a reef if a pest is ever multiplying itself. If you've seen valonia problems like I had in my one tank, or in other tanks in my travels, you'd opt for a serious solution as well.

The valonia problem I ended up having over a period of about a year by meticulously manually removing them, rinsing the rock before putting back into the tank was totally out of hand. There was no other solution to rid my tank of valonia other than boiling the rock, taking the tank down and bleaching the tank and all the equipment. Hard decision to make, but one well worth it in the end as it turned out.

I cured the killed, stinking rock and eventually used it as base rock in an upgraded tank. Looking at that tank now, I can't tell anymore what was boiled and what came from the lfs. Must be the Mg that brought that rock back to life :lol: :razz: And no freaking valonia in the other tank, either :2gunfire:

From now on, give me a hammer and screwdriver or wire cutters to excise the rock around the valonia so the bubble doesn't break and no more problem.

ya it does apear to work like that but from what I have read (disclamer:mrgreen: ) and from my own expereance, I have found it is almost like a cycle depending on the nutreants. it starts apearing slowly then more and more so you start popping them to get rid of them and holy **** you have millions, but I have done it a different way as you describred by removing the rocks and completly removing them and the same spreadig rate happend as when I just removed them and didn't care about breaking them. I think once they go sexual they release babies that have a planktonic stage untill they settel down and start growing so it can seem like breaking them is causing the spread but if you look around you will find a white shell of one that went sexual on you.

Steve