Actually she did infer that by saying "I would extend my own personal definition of puppy mills to include breeders who produce inventory to stock pet stores."

Since Wolf bred puppies that went to a pet store, that would make them a puppy mill operator by Emily's logic. No?

No, it would not. Wolf is not in the business of producing inventory for pet stores. He did it once, and realized that it wasn't a good idea for the benefit of his pups and did not do it again. He made a mistake. He learned from it.

Also Reef Raf, i noticed you used the phrase "reputable breeder" in your last post. Saying that Wolf may end up being a reputable breeder. According to you this is not possible. Earlier, i tried to get you to clarify your views on the phrase "reputable breeder" by saying....

"So reef_raf, by your rational, no matter the caliber of a dog breeder and the amount of care the put into producing healthy, happy puppies conforming to breed standards, if they sold thier litter to a pet store they would cease to be a reputable breeder? This one feature will erase all other indications of a good reputation?"

You replied to this by saying, "Yes, exactly. Now you're getting my point. Good breeders do not sell to pet shops, they just don't."

So how could Wolf ever become a repuatable breeder having sold his dogs to a Pet Store? You seemed fairly absolute in your statement. I am confused, I do read the posts and you don't seem to make much sense.

Actually, it was posted that the first FEW batches of puppies went to a Pet store. Few usually indicates plural, maybe you should read more closely.

Ok, few. Then he realized it was wrong. Lesson still learned.

And there is the problem. Now, I said a reputable breeder does not sell to pet stores. Wolf sold to pet stores, and that, IMO, disqualifies him as a reputable breeder. He has since stopped doing that. Now my last phrase was that in time, he may or may not become a reputable breeder. If he continues breeding, and gains a good reputation, he could become a reputable breeder. And he no longer sells to pet stores, which meets one of the criteria. While he did sell, then no, he did not meet my definition of "reputable". That can change.
Now please stop trying to twist all of this for the sake of arguing.

Anyway, I'm done with this thread, me and my pound puppy are going for a run at the lake. You and your dogs have a great weekend!! :)

but you agreed that "This one feature will erase all other indications of a good reputation?"

So the reputable breeder vs non-repuatable breeder argument is not as absolute as you would have previously indicated?

did you see my last post?? My dog is bouncing at the door. Gotta run. Agree with me. Don't agree with me. Don't care. Take your dog to the park. Have a great day.

sorry i missed it, have a great weekend. I'm more of a cat person.